Monday, December 10, 2007

Eagle Vs Shark; Hunting & Gathering; War/Dance


There is little need to extrapolate upon the success Napoleon Dynamite, and the way in which this film’s particular brand of ‘geek-humour’ rippled through pop culture, inspiring a whole breed of people who insist on quoting lines to the point of banality, the proliferation of a particular slogan shirt, and, apparently, this recent New Zealand comedy flick. In Taika Cohen’s Eagle Vs Shark we meet Lilly (Loren Horsley), a pathetically weak yet well-meaning fast-food worker, in love with Jarrod (Jemaine Clement), a mulleted, baselessly arrogant electronic store clerk. After proving herself worthy through an impressive video game performance, Jarrod is soon asking Lilly out, standing her up, excusing himself with the excuse over “I’m just so complex,” and eventually taking her with him to visit his hometown, in a trip that gives him a chance to finally avenge his high school nemesis and Cohen a chance to play Lilly off against Jarrod’s dysfunctional family. At no point along this journey does Cohen shy away from blatant ND references (nam-chucks, ‘liger’-esque sketches and that trademark flat delivery all make an appearance). Cohen’s only attempt at an original edge is her effort to look further beneath the surface, but this is largely manifest through self-consciously poignant asides that do little to rectify the situation (and significantly also feel reminiscent of a million other indie flicks along the lines of Garden State). There are some delightful moments (including Cohen’s stop motion sequences, the film’s cute final scene and admittedly the entire character of the amiable Lilly), and, certainly, if it had been released three years earlier then the film would no doubt be a cult classic. As is, though, it is not worth watching this one more than once, because you’ve already seen it all before to start with.

Rating: 7.3

Adapted from a 600 page novel by celebrated author Anna Gavalda, Hunting and Gathering marks the first time that veteran French filmmaker Claude Berri (Jean de Florette, The Housekeeper) has looked towards a younger generation for his subjects. The film tracks the lives of three, vastly different 20-something year-olds over the course of a year, as they are unexpectedly thrust into a shared living space. Philibert (Laurent Stocker) is a kind-hearted, stuttering aristocrat temporarily looking after a large, regal apartment for his wealthy family, Franck (Guilaume Canet) is his temperamental housemate and Camille (Audrey Tautou) is their lost and lonely neighbour, who Philibert takes under his wings after she develops the flu. There are some touching moments (particularly thanks to Philibert) and the performances are all impressive (especially Francoise Bertin in a gracious turn of Franck’s grandmother Paulette), but on the whole the film suffers slightly from the stilted feel of inadequate adaptation. The narrative jumps through developments with an awkward swiftness, the story’s romantic plotline feels like it must have been drastically simplified and, although Berri did make many changes to the original novel, he did not inject enough structure into the story’s flowing narrative to make it feel like a movie rather than an extended episode of television drama. This is a sweet movie, but it just doesn’t pack a punch, or the melancholic flavour one could have expected from this director.

Rating: 7.0

This Monday, the US/Ugandan documentary War/Dance opens at Joondalup Pines for PIAF’s Lotterywest Film Festival. Gifted with an extraordinary story and some colourful interview characters, War/Dance is a compelling look at the poverty stricken Achioli tribe in northern Uganda, where a class at the Patonga refugee camp primary school has been asked to compete in a nationwide music and dance competition in Kampala. The students, many of whom are orphaned, have seen the atrocities of war first hand, and lived amongst conflict their entire life. By focusing on three outspoken class members, we learn of their unbelievable individual sufferings and the potential of music and passion to provide relief in amongst the darkest circumstances. Like some sort of cross between sweet innocence of Mad Hot Ballroom and the powerful emotion of Born Into Brothels, this documentary is compelling and, ultimately, deeply affecting.

Rating: 7.9

No comments: